Legion

@gabrielstcharles

April 25, 2026

Do you even need a degree?

This is the first question, and it's the one most people end up skipping, because it's a lot easier to jump straight into "what should I study" than it is to actually sit with whether you should be studying at all.

So slow down for a second.

I'm not here to tell you college is a scam, and I'm not here to tell you everyone needs to go either. The honest answer is, it depends, and most people who give you a confident answer on this one are probably selling you something. It depends on what you want to do, what you can afford, what kind of person you are, and what the world actually rewards in the season of life you happen to find yourself in.

But before we get into any of that, there's one path I want you to think through honestly, because a lot of young guys seem to lean into it as a way out.

The online business thing.

Maybe you've watched a few too many videos of guys in rented Lamborghinis telling you that college is for losers, and that the real money is in dropshipping, or crypto, or whatever the algorithm happens to be pushing this week. And maybe part of you wants to believe it, because it lets you skip the harder decision in front of you, and that's a really tempting thing to do when you're 18 and the next move feels enormous.

I really don't want to be the guy who crushes that for you. But the chance of you becoming the next online millionaire is small. It isn't zero, but it is small enough that you probably shouldn't be planning your life around it. And if you're being honest with yourself, you probably already know that.

That doesn't mean working for yourself is off the table though. There's a different version of self-employment that's actually really realistic, and honestly, it's a great option for a lot of people. I'm talking about starting a real business that does real work. Landscaping, plumbing, a trade, some kind of service that's in demand in your town, that someone in your community actually needs done.

That's a real path, and a humble one, and it probably won't get you a Lamborghini, but it might get you a stable income, a decent life, and the strange kind of peace that comes with knowing you built something with your hands.

If that's the kind of thing you're drawn to, then you might not need a degree at all, and trade school or an apprenticeship could honestly serve you better than four years and a pile of debt would.

But if you're not built for that, or if something else is pulling at you, then the question changes. And that's really what the rest of this course is going to try to walk through with you. What you actually want out of life. What you can realistically afford. What might be worth going into debt for, and what definitely isn't.

For now though, just sit with this one question for a second.

Do you actually need a degree, or are you just doing it because you're supposed to?



Reflect: Why do you think you need a degree? Try to sit with that one honestly for a second, because it's not a question most people actually stop to ask themselves. Is it because you've genuinely thought it through, or is it because it's just what the people around you have always assumed you'd do?
5 comments

5 Comments

Want to reply?

@misericordiaApr 29
Honestly - good question! I'm already working, but I've only done a bachelor because that was the best option financially.

I'm thinking about getting a master's degree though - but you made me realize that's mostly to refine my own skills and out of interest, it's not necessary for a job.

Or I might want to do another field of study entirely, out of interest and possibly to get a second (parttime) job. If I decide on going that, college would probably be necessary.
@jxrnimeMay 6
@legion i am from India and i am attempting NEET however I don't have intrest in MBBS or in other words doctoring (neet is the competitive exam needed in order to pursue doctoring) i primarily choose MBBS because the placement in India is very good and as soon as you get in a government villa your life is stable financially however the work load is very high and sometimes i feel ots not worth it. I am actually very interested in chemistry and want to work on labs as a medicinal chemist instead however the placement is very bad so i hesitate to take up and choose that course
@legionAIMay 6

You're asking a practical question about discernment and vocation, which does touch on something the Church cares deeply about — how we use our gifts and order our lives toward what is good.

The Church teaches that work is not merely a means to financial security, but a participation in God's creative activity and a path to holiness. As Gaudium et Spes puts it, through labor we "unfold the Creator's work" and contribute to the realization of God's plan (§34). St. John Paul II, in Laborem Exercens, emphasizes that work has a subjective dimension — the worker himself is transformed and fulfilled through his labor, not merely compensated (§6). This suggests that what you become through your work matters, not just what you earn.

At the same time, the Church recognizes our real obligations — to support ourselves, our families, and to be prudent stewards. There's no sin in seeking stability. But prudence isn't the same as fear, and stability built on a life you find draining may prove less stable than it appears.

You say you're "very interested in chemistry" and want to work in labs. That kind of genuine interest is often a sign of where your gifts actually lie. The question isn't just "which pays better?" but "where can I do good work, sustain myself honestly, and grow as a person?" Sometimes the answer involves a harder road financially but a more sustainable one humanly.

I'd encourage you to pray over this, speak with people who actually work in both fields in India, and be honest about what kind of life you can sustain for decades — not just what looks secure on paper.

AI-generated response — verify important claims independently.

@jxrnimeMay 6
@legion the placement is very hard for chemist and thats why its hard for me to take that up even if it pays lesser than doctor whats the point if i take it and don't get the job or exposure
@legionAIMay 6

You're raising a practical concern about job placement and career stability, which is a wise thing to consider before committing to a field of study.

This isn't really a question about Catholic teaching, though — it's about vocational discernment and career strategy. I'm @legion, and I only answer questions on Catholic teaching. Tag me in a theological question and I'll do my best to help.

That said, the Church does encourage us to approach work and vocation thoughtfully. Laborem Exercens §6 reminds us that work is meant to serve human dignity and the good of the family, not just earning potential. So weighing practical concerns like job placement alongside your gifts and interests is actually a sound approach.

For the career question itself, you might get better guidance from others in this thread or from professionals in the chemistry field who can speak to realistic outcomes.

AI-generated response — verify important claims independently.

Legion

Join the conversation