The scandal crisis and young Catholics — honest conversation

The abuse scandals have been the single biggest challenge to my faith and to the faith of almost every young Catholic I know. I stayed. Many did not. I want to understand what kept other young Catholics in the Church through it — not the easy answer (the Church is more than her failures) but the actual interior journey. What did you have to work through?

6 comments

6 Comments

Want to reply?

@unknownMar 10

What kept me in: the Eucharist, which I could not explain away. And the intellectual tradition — once I had read Augustine, Aquinas, Newman, I realised I was not choosing between the Church and intelligence but between the Church and a much shallower alternative. The institutional failures are real but the Church is not finally the institution.

@edith_sMar 10

I had to separate "the Church has failed" from "the Church's claims are false." These are logically distinct. If anything, the scandals demonstrate the Church's own teaching about sin and concupiscence. The institution is made of sinners — it has never claimed otherwise. What would actually refute the faith is if the Church denied the gravity of these sins, which it does not.

@patrick_hughesMar 11

I left for three years. I came back because I could not stay away from the Eucharist and I could not find a coherent alternative. But I came back with open eyes — demanding reform, refusing to pretend the crimes were less than they were. The naive filial piety of my childhood faith is gone. What replaced it is something harder and, I think, more honest.

@gabrielstcharlesMar 12

@legion how should we feel about the Church scandals?

✦

@legionAIMar 12

The scandal of abuse within the Church is a profound wound — to victims first and foremost, but also to the entire Body of Christ. The Church herself has spoken to this with unusual directness.

Pope Benedict XVI, in his 2010 Letter to the Catholics of Ireland, called the abuse "sinful and criminal" and acknowledged that it was "often badly handled" by Church leaders. He wrote that the sins committed against young people "must be a constant call to humility and trust in God's healing grace." Pope Francis has been similarly blunt, calling clericalism — the distorted elevation of clergy above accountability — a root cause, and insisting that "no effort must be spared" to prevent future abuse and to bring healing to victims (Letter to the People of God, 2018).

What should you feel? The Church does not dictate your emotions, but she does affirm that righteous anger at injustice is not sinful — Christ Himself overturned tables. Grief, confusion, even a sense of betrayal are legitimate responses to genuine evil. The Catechism reminds us that scandal "is a grave offense" especially when committed by those charged with teaching (CCC §2285).

What many young Catholics have worked through is this: the holiness of the Church is found in Christ and the sacraments He instituted, not in the personal virtue of every minister. The Church is semper reformanda — always in need of reform — precisely because she is made up of sinners. Staying is not about excusing evil; it is about clinging to the One who remains when all else fails.

AI-generated response — verify important claims independently.

@aidantiumMar 24

I am not perfect. Neither are those who committed the abuses. The reality is that they were tempted and succumbed to the temptation. Either they were wicked individuals who infiltrated the church ranks or they were manipulated by the Evil One. Either way, the dispensation of the person is of no relation to the Truth that Jesus produces through the church